PB&J vs. Clif Bar - Ski Mag

PB&J vs. Clif Bar

One costs pennies, the other about a buck-twenty-something. Both are delicious things to keep you fueled during a ski day. But we asked a nutritionist: What's the difference?
Author:
Publish date:
Social count:
17
Clifbar.jpg

Is the DIY lunchbox special as good as the go-anywhere Clif Bar? According to registered dietitian and skier Carrie Gleeksman, who works at Denver’s National Jewish Medical and Research Center, peanut butter and jelly holds up against the high-tech bar. “PB&J is good for skiing,” she says. “Just one sandwich may provide enough energy for a half day.” The caveat, of course, is that she recommends defiling the sublimity of the Wonder Bread–Jif combo with hippie ingredients. “Whole-grain bread supplies good portions of fiber, and natural PB provides monounsaturated fats instead of the trans fats you’d get with Jif,” says Gleeksman. “And any old jam gives you simple sugars,” which are good for energy. We added a few other scientific criteria to see how it holds up.


PB&J
Calories: 470
Carbs: 68g
Fat: 18g
Protein: 16g
Cost: Pennies
Squishy: Yes
Organic: Your call
Can it level a shaky table? Sadly, no
Transportable? Some breaching may occur
Made by a Cordon Bleu chef? Not unless you’re a Cordon Bleu chef
Flavor: Salty and sweet
Flava: Original gangsta
Nostalgia: Your lunchbox’s only untraded item

Clif Bar’s chocolate chip peanut crunch
Calories: 250
Carbs: 43g
Fat: 6g
Protein: 11g
Cost: $1.29
Squishy: No
Organic: Yes
Can it level a shaky table? Yes
Transportable? Fully
Made by a Cordon Bleu chef? Yes (seriously)
Flavor: 15 different flavors
Flava: For the heart-rate-monitor crowd
Nostalgia: Named after the founder’s dad

VERDICT: Clif Bar, by a nose.

Related

Energy Bar

Energy Bars Decoded

That energy bar you're eating on the lift might not be as good for you as you think. Here are ingredients to avoid, and how to make your own bars.

JuliavLindsey

Lindsey vs. Julia: Catfight?

One girl's a media darling with a banged up shin and a medley of World Cup victories. The other is a Victoria's Secret-style vixen with a bad back and a gold medal. Ski racer Lindsey Vonn wants what Julia Mancuso's already got: an Olympic gold. You can watch them go head to head during Wednesday's Olympic downhill in Whistler.

skg1208punk_at.jpg

Punked: Alta vs. Snowbird

The pranks have involved explosives, goats, mannequins, doughnuts, and nudity. Each year on April Fools' Day, the Snowbird and Alta patrollers punk each other, sometimes spawning real panic and organized rescue. Is this the year they get busted?